Choosing Between Siemens Unified Comfort and Basic Panels: Engineer’s FAQ
If you're working on HMI and drive projects and wondering about the real-world differences between Siemens' Unified Comfort and Unified Basic panels, you're not alone. These are questions I get from customers all the time. Here’s a quick breakdown to help you pick the right gear for your application without overcomplicating it.
Unified Comfort vs. Unified Basic Panels
Q: Do I need a license to use Unified panels?
Short answer: Yes, but it depends on the panel.
- Unified Comfort panels require either a Comfort, Unified Comfort, or higher license.
- Unified Basic panels, on the other hand, are more flexible. You can use a Step 7 TIA Portal Basic/Professional license, or any level of WinCC license.
So if you’re looking to keep licensing costs low and only need basic HMI functionality, Unified Basic might be the way to go.
Q: Can I use these panels with other PLCs?
Absolutely. Both Unified Comfort and Basic panels support select 3rd-party drivers, much like the older Comfort panels. This is a big deal for standardization. You can deploy the same HMI across different PLC platforms, which means:
- Less operator training
- Familiar screens, regardless of the controller
- Easier maintenance across mixed environments
Q: What about remote access?
Yes, you can view your screen remotely using VNC and smart client tools. Unified panels also offer a more seamless experience through a web client right in your browser.
Keep in mind the client limits:
- Unified Basic supports 1 remote client
- Unified Comfort supports up to 3
Bonus Tip: Siemens offers starter kits that bundle everything you need (panel, license, etc.) at a reduced cost. If you're starting fresh or prototyping, this is a solid way to get going without overspending.
Choosing the Right Fit for Your Application
When deciding between Unified Comfort and Basic panels, think about the complexity of your HMI needs. Unified Comfort panels offer more advanced features like multi-touch screens, higher resolution displays, better performance, and extended scripting capabilities—ideal for more complex visualizations or applications with a lot of user interaction.
Unified Basic panels, while simpler, are more than capable for standard tasks like machine status displays, simple alarms, and basic control interfaces. If you're working on cost-sensitive projects or repetitive machinery where visual demands are low, Basic panels can significantly reduce both hardware and software investment without sacrificing reliability.
Conclusion
Whether it’s a simpler or more complex panel, the key is picking the right tool for the job. Unified panels make it easy to streamline your HMI environment, especially when you're juggling different PLCs. GCG Automation & Factory Solutions is a leading Siemens distributor in the nation and can get you started on your path to success in automation.
Have more questions? I'd love to help. Let's connect now.